The U.S. provided $130 million to UNRWA in 2013. UNRWA’s continued operations in Gaza would not be viable without American funding. Congressional investigations and condemnations have led nowhere. UNRWA has adopted neutrality policies, but it has refused to put up a firewall between it and Hamas. And it can’t, because it has become an arm of Hamas.
By Daniel Greenfield | August 11, 2014
UNRWA is on the front lines of the Hamas War in Gaza. In the headlines, its schools are forever being fired on or found to be stockpiling rockets. If individual Gazans are being used as human shields, UNRWA often seems as if it is one big organizational human shield.
But UNRWA isn’t Hamas’ human shield. UNRWA is Hamas.
The “UN” part of UNRWA, the blue logos and symbols, fool us into thinking of it as an international humanitarian organization. But UNRWA in Gaza functions as a large Palestinian Arab organization with a smattering of foreign supervisory staff.
And those foreign staffers often tend to leave during a conflict.
UNRWA is not an international organization operating in the Middle East. Effectively it’s a local Arab Muslim organization funded and regulated internationally. Since UNRWA classifies 80% of Gazans as “refugees,” it administers the biggest welfare state in the world on their behalf. Like the Palestinian Authority, UNRWA’s welfare state is run locally and funded internationally.
UNRWA is the biggest employer in the West Bank and Gaza after the Palestinian Authority and the vast majority of its employees are “locally recruited.” Varying figures place the share of local employees at between 90 and 99 percent.
Even though there are more Arab Muslims living in the West Bank than in Gaza, there are more “official” refugees in Gaza, which means that more UNRWA funding and efforts are directed there. UNRWA only runs 96 schools in the West Bank, but it runs 245 schools in Gaza. It employs less than 3,000 education staffers in the West Bank, but over 10,000 in Gaza.
Why does Hamas, which is obsessed with brainwashing the next generation into martyrdom, allow a foreign organization to run an educational system for 232,000 pupils?
It’s because in Gaza, Hamas and UNRWA are the same thing.
When there was talk of reforming UNRWA by removing Hamas members from its ranks, the editor of a Hamas newspaper wrote, “Laying off the agency employees because of their political affiliation means laying off all the employees of the aid agency, because…they are all members of the ‘resistance,’ in its various forms.”
The official word from Hamas was that it and UNRWA are the same thing. UNRWA’s vast majority of locally sourced Gazans are part of Hamas.
UNRWA does not see that as a problem.
“I am sure that there are Hamas members on the UNRWA payroll,” a former UNRWA Commissioner General said, “and I don’t see that as a crime.”
“Hamas as a political organization does not mean that every member is a militant, and we do not do political vetting and exclude people from one persuasion as against another,” he said.
Also, if UNRWA fired Hamas members from its Gaza staff, it would have no one left.
UNRWA schools are Hamas bases of recruitment and operation
Hamas’ control over UNRWA in Gaza is reflected in the schools which promote Islamic terrorism. It’s unsurprising that UNRWA schools have repeatedly become flashpoints in conflicts between Israel and Hamas. The members of the Islamic terrorist group aren’t invading UNRWA schools to use them as human shields. These UNRWA schools are Hamas bases of recruitment and operation.
The current accusations and counter-accusations over attacks on and from UNRWA schools are a reenactment of the same set of events from 2009. Only the locations and the names have changed. The same headlines, “Israeli shelling kills dozens at UN school in Gaza,” and “Massacre of Innocents as UN school is shelled” are repeating all over again.
Then, as now, Hamas launched attacks on Israeli forces from around an UNRWA school. Then it turned out that the attack had happened outside the school and no one had actually died inside the school. Nothing has changed since then. The “massacres” in which Hamas terrorists using UNRWA schools as a base are killed pop up in every newspaper. UNRWA repeats the same lies.
Then it “discovers” Hamas rockets in three of its schools. And that’s just the tip of the iceberg because every UNRWA school is a Hamas school.
UNRWA has admitted that Hamas uses its schools to store rockets. It admits that it has Hamas members in its ranks. It admits that rockets have been fired “into Israel from the vicinity of UN facilities and residential areas.”
What it refuses to admit is that it should in any way be held accountable for functioning as an arm of a terrorist organization.
If an organization consists largely of Hamas members who use it to pursue Hamas goals, then the organization is Hamas.
UNRWA is Hamas
Hamas’ use of UNRWA as its public face is a war crime, but terrorists commit war crimes without a second thought. The UN and UNRWA are complicit in this war crime by allowing Hamas to go on exploiting the UN brand. It’s unfortunately commonplace for humanitarian organizations in war zones to collaborate with terrorists and guerrillas in one form or another. But UNRWA isn’t just paying money to Hamas in exchange for being allowed to operate, the way that many groups in war zones do, it has allowed Hamas to turn its operations in Gaza into an extension of the terrorist group.
Hamas is listed as a Designated Foreign Terrorist Organization by the U.S. Department of State. It’s against the law for the United States to fund it. By funding UNRWA, the United States is paying Hamas and participating in its war crimes. Using civilian and humanitarian facilities for military purposes is a war crime. Using them to stage attacks against civilians by attackers out of uniform adds further crimes to the total.
The United States provided $130 million to UNRWA in 2013. UNRWA’s continued operations in Gaza would not be viable without American funding. Congressional investigations and condemnations have led nowhere. UNRWA has adopted neutrality policies, but it has refused to put up a firewall between it and Hamas. And it can’t, because it has become an arm of Hamas.
When Kerry visited Gaza in 2009, UNRWA’s Gaza chief passed along a letter to him from Hamas. The incident showed that not only was the locally recruited staff working for Hamas, but UNRWA leadership was clearly cooperating with the terrorist group.
The original “refugees” that UNRWA was set up to cater to are for the most part dead. UNRWA has become another UN boondoggle funding a welfare state for “refugee camps” that are older, bigger and more developed than many Middle Eastern cities.
Meanwhile, UNRWA has become the public face of Hamas.
UNRWA staff act as terrorists when they use UNRWA facilities for military purposes, but then switch back to UNRWA when Israel fights back. Hamas carries out attacks. UNRWA demands ceasefires. Hamas uses UNRWA schools and UNRWA denounces Israel when an attack happens.
UNRWA has become the mask that Hamas wears. It’s a tactical asset for a terrorist group that empowers its human shield strategy. UNRWA is not only endangering Israeli civilians, but it is also endangering Gazans who are exploited as human shields by members of a terrorist group masquerading as the staff of an international humanitarian organization.
This issue has come up before and UNRWA’s long record of evasions and denials, admitting the substance of the claims about the Hamas takeover of UNRWA, while insisting that its Hamas members are neutral and that all the rocket stores and rocket attacks around UNRWA facilities are unrelated to the Hamas members on its staff, are not good enough anymore.
It’s time to defund UNRWA
Although, UNRWA apologists will insist that without it Hamas will have full control over the educational and social services of Gaza. But Hamas already controls those through UNRWA while using American taxpayer money to spread hate and promote terrorism.
Hamas would not tolerate an outside organization controlling education in Gaza. The only reason it tolerates UNRWA is because it can use its people in the schools while UNRWA funds the whole thing with American and European money. The moment UNRWA is defunded, Hamas will kick it out and the same teachers will go on teaching the same hateful material, but without the UN logos.
The United States should not be in the business of funding the corruption of young minds. Money should not be taken from American schools to fund the spread of hatred and terrorism.
Bills have been filed in Congress and investigations have been launched. Congressmen and Senators have looked into UNRWA, clucked their tongues and denounced its practices, but now it’s time to take action by defunding UNRWA.
Daniel Greenfield is a New York City-based writer and freelance commentator with a special focus on the War on Terror and the rising threat to Western Civilization. Mr. Greenfield is a Shillman Journalism Fellow at the Freedom Center. He maintains a blog and is a contributor to SFPPR News & Analysis.